Google+ Reading Teen: A New Twist on a Review: Prophecy of the Sisters by Michelle Zink

Monday, August 16, 2010

A New Twist on a Review: Prophecy of the Sisters by Michelle Zink

    Prophecy of the Sisters (Prophecy of the Sisters Trilogy, Book I)
  • Reading level: Young Adult
  • Paperback: 368 pages
  • Publisher: Little, Brown Books for Young Readers; 1 edition (July 1, 2010)
  • Language: English
  • ISBN-10: 0316027413
  • ISBN-13: 978-0316027410
An ancient prophecy divides two sisters--one good, one evil.

Who will prevail?

Twin sisters Lia and Alice Milthorpe have just become orphans. They have also become enemies. As they discover their roles in a prophecy that has turned generations of sisters against each other, they find themselves entangled in a mystery that involves a tattoo-like mark, their parents' deaths, a boy, a book, and a lifetime of secrets.

Prophecy of the Sisters(I actually like the original cover better, so I'm posting it too!)

Prophecy of the Sisters has been out for awhile, but I hadn't heard of it until I received an ARC of Guardian of the Gate.  The premise was intriguing and the cover just looked creepy, so I picked up Prophecy at the library.  I decided that since it has been out awhile, and there are already a lot of reviews of it out there, that I would do my review a little differently.  I decided to write down my thoughts as I read (without spoilers).  I hope you enjoy my journey through this book!

Ch. 1
-I'm immediately in love with the writing.  I can tell that the story is happening a long time in the past.  The mark on Lia's wrist is intriguing, as is Alice's mysterious behavior. -- I'm hooked!

Ch. 2
-What secrets is the "Dark Room" hiding.  I'm seriously freaking out.  My heart is pounding.  This chapter is reading like a horror movie and I love it!  What is behind her parents' untimely deaths?  And what is her sister up to?  Alice is creeping me out!

Ch. 3
-It's interesting to start a story where the romance has already begun.  James and Lia have been friends since childhood, but are now in love.  I like James immediately!  He seems kind and sensitive with an air of mischievousness about him.  Their relationship is sweet and romantic!

Ch. 4
-I love Lia's curiosity and her unwillingness to turn her back on a mystery, even though the truth may be frightening......I'd like to punch Alice......

Ch. 5
-Well, my heart is racing again, as the sisters have a strange encounter with Sonia Sorrensen, a spiritualist who can speak with the dead.  It's so strange how different Alice and Lia are considering they're twins.  Alice's friend, Victoria is a complete stuck-up snob, but I like Lia's new friend, Luisa, right away!

Ch. 6-7
I'm loving the fact that I haven't read anything about this book.  I have no idea what's happening, other than there's two sisters and a mysterious prophecy.  Fascinating bits and pieces are slowly being revealed.

Ch. 8-10
-More things being revealed.  I feel sorry for Lia's crippled younger brother, Henry.  He misses his father so much and Alice is obviously doing something to scare him.  Lia treats him kindly but Alice is very disturbing.

Ch. 11
-Lia, Sophia, and Luisa become fast friends as they try to decipher the Prophecy in a race against time and against Alice.

WOW!  BLINDSIDE!  I did NOT see that coming!

Ch. 12
-Wondering more than ever what happened to Lia's parents.  Why didn't they explain anything to Lia before they died?

Ch. 13-15
-I don't want to say too much because I don't want to give anything away.  The decaying relationship between the sisters is sad to read.  But I think I've figured out what the Keys are....

Ch. 16-21
-I was right!!  Well....partially right, anyway!  P.S.  I love Edmund!

Ch. 22
-I'm in constant fear that Alice will overhear Lia and her friends as they try to unravel the prophecy.  My stomach is in knots!  Be careful, Lia!

Ch. 23-27
-Why doesn't someone ship Alice off to boarding school?  Or better yet, push her off a cliff!  AHH!!

Ch. 28
-I really wish that the people who are continually saving/helping Lia would teach her how to fight for herself.  It's not that she isn't willing to learn.  She's totally ready to fight, she just can't get anyone to give her enough information!

Ch. 29
-AHH!!!  I want to scream, "WAKE UP LIA!!!  It's right in front of your face!!"

Ch. 30
-Holy Crap!!  As I sit on my back porch reading this chapter, the sky has turned from sunshine to clouds and the ominous sound of thunder is getting closer and fitting.....

Ch. 31
-"....the rain is incessant, and I see nothing that gives me hope."-Lia
-My heart is pounding again, and I've noticed that I keep clicking my pen over and over again....this is intense.

Ch. 32-35
My emotions have run the gamut in this book and especially in these last few chapters.  Some things are revealed about the prophecy and the roles that the sisters will play, but many questions are left unanswered.  At my house, the rain has stopped and the sun has that a sign of things to come?  I guess I'll have to read The Guardian of the Gate to find out.  Luckily it's sitting right here!

5 out of 6 

Overall this was a really exciting and fantastically written story.  It read kind of slowly in parts, but not in a bad, boring way at all.  More like and old-time gothic way.  Plus it was very clean, which you all know is a plus in my book!  I would definitely recommend it!

Parents should know:  This book had no language or sexual content.  There was some kissing, but nothing too detailed. 


  1. I liked this review. I think you were born to do this stuff! Call me, I want to go to lunch!

  2. So glad I found your blog! I love reading what fellow bloggers ahve to say!

  3. Must... Read....!!!!!... ;D

    This sounds so intriguing! I'm adding it to my to-read list right now. I think it was mostly your Alice comments that hooked me. :D

    Thanks for the awesome review!

  4. Great idea! Loved your review format! :D

  5. I just finished this one as well and really enjoyed it. There are a few things that bothered me, but the overall story was fantastic. And I love that you changed up your review format, it's nice you keep things fresh and interesting for your readers:)

  6. Thanks for all the compliments!! Maybe I'll try this format again sometime :)


Leave us a comment. Commenting people are our favorites! And we like to give things to favorites :)